Neighbors evacuated while dozens of police surrounded home where a DeRuyter couple was found dead Monday in what police believe was a murder-suicide.
DeRuyter, NY -- Jessica Kosturik’s first hint that something was wrong at the home of her next-door neighbors, Michele and Edward Green, came when she got a call at 8:30 Sunday night.
It was the bartender at the Coalyard Tavern down the street in this tiny Madison County town 37 miles southeast of Syracuse. Michele Green had a part-time job cleaning the bar on weekend mornings and had not shown up for work Sunday, the bartender said.
The call started a bizarre night in which Kosturik and her fiancé had to flee their home through a window and spend the rest of the night in, first, a fire station and then a church while dozens of police surrounded the Greens’ home.
Early Monday morning, police entered the Greens’ home at 1599 Seminary St. and found Michele and Edward Green, both 48, dead from an apparent murder-suicide.
Police have released few details about the deaths. But Kosturik’s fiancé, Jason Hodge Sr., said a trooper told him that police believe Edward Green killed his wife on Saturday and then killed himself after police arrived Sunday night.
The couple died in their two-story home directly across the street from DeRuyter Central School, where Michele Green worked full time as a secretary for 19 years. The school, which has 410 students from kindergarten to Grade 12, was closed Monday after officials learned of Michele Green’s death. Classes will be delayed two hours Tuesday and counselors will be available for students and staff.
Kosturik said she has known the Greens well since she began renting her home from Edward Green nine years ago. So when the Coalyard bartender called asking if she had seen Michele, she tried calling her cell phone. There was no answer.
Then she texted her but got no response. So she and Hodge went next door and knocked on the Greens’ door. Again, no response. The lights were out, but the Greens’ dog was inside barking.
Soon, the Greens’ son, Ryan, who also had been unable to reach his parents, arrived at the home. But sensing something was terribly wrong, he called the police instead of trying to break into the home, Kosturik said.
Jessica Kosturik and her fiance, Jason Hodge Sr., at their home in DeRuyter. The couple live next door to the home where their friends, Michele and Edward Green, died in an apparent murder-suicide.
Rick Moriarty | rmoriarty@syracuse.com
Police arrived about 9:45 p.m., and two troopers entered the house. They didn’t stay long. Hodge said both came running out of the house about 10 seconds after entering it.
“They said, ‘Get down. The suspect has a gun. Clear the area. The suspect has a gun,’” said Hodge.
Police said that when the troopers entered the house, they found Edward Green standing in the kitchen holding a shotgun. The troopers quickly withdrew from the home and, shortly afterward, heard a gunshot, police said.
Hodge said he and Kosturik rushed back into their home, which is just 30 feet from the Greens’ home. Soon, dozens of State Police and Madison County deputies were surrounding the Greens’ home with guns drawn, Hodge said.
Hodge and Kosturik stood in their kitchen, lights out, watching police crawling all over their yard. Then, shortly after midnight, their phone rang again. It was the State Police. They wanted Hodge, Kosturik and her 15-year-old daughter to evacuate the house for their safety.
The three of them crawled out a rear window so they would not be in the line of any potential fire from the Greens’ home, Kosturik said.
Police drove them to the DeRuyter fire station around the corner and told them to stay there with a few other neighbors who also were evacuated from the street.
After a couple of hours, they moved across the street to the St. Lawrence Catholic Church. They stayed there until about 5:30 a.m., when a woman came into the church from the fire station and delivered the bad news.
“She said, ‘It’s not good. They’re both dead,’” said Hodge.
Police said a special operations response team entered the house about 4:30 a.m. and found the couple dead from gunshot wounds.
Residents left flowers on the stairs of DeRuyter Central School Monday afternoon. Michele Green, a secretary at the school, and her husband, Edward, were found dead in their home across the street from the school Monday morning in what police believe was a murder-suicide.
Rick Moriarty | rmoriarty@syracuse.com
Hodge and Kosturik returned to their home stunned. Police soon strung yellow crime-scene tape around the Greens’ property as troopers closed off their street to traffic and investigators went in and out of the house the rest of the morning.
“There were police everywhere,” said Hodge.
Kosturik said she and Michele had become good friends over the years.
“She was an incredible woman,” she said. “She would do absolutely anything for anybody, whether she knew you or not.”
She was not as close to Edward Green, who she said worked at a company in Cortland. But she said he was friendly to her.
“I’d be sitting there talking to Michele and he’d come into the kitchen and say, ‘Hi, what’s up, girl?’” she said.
She and Hodge said they heard nothing unusual at the Greens’ home Saturday or during the day Sunday. Hodge said he noticed that someone in the residence let the couple’s dog out of the house around 4 p.m. Sunday. He did not see who it was.
Early Monday afternoon, Hodge and Kosturik joined about 75 other residents of this small community at a prayer service for the Greens at United Church of DeRuyter a few blocks from the Greens’ home. Many, like Kosturik and Hodge, brought flowers.
“It’s for people just to get together and comfort each other,” said Denise Cuddeback, of DeRuyter.
“She was well known here,” she said of Michele Green.
A 6 p.m. candlelight service was also held at the Catholic church, Cuddeback said.
Contact Rick Moriarty at rmoriarty@syracuse.com or (315) 470-3148. Follow him on Twitter @RickMoriartyCNY and on Facebook at rick.moriarty.92.