James "Thumper" Steen and Roger Breckenridge have been implicated by seven new witnesses each in the 1994 kidnapping.
OSWEGO, N.Y. - If the Heidi Allen kidnapping investigation were a numbers game, the three new alleged suspects would be way ahead of the guy who's been sitting in prison for 21 years.
A total of 14 people have come forward over the past two years with evidence linking James "Thumper" Steen, Roger Breckenridge or Michael Bohrer to the crime.
Two people said 21 years ago they heard Gary Thibodeau make an admission - and those were two men who were in jail at the time. One new witness says he heard someone implicate Thibodeau.
Some of the witnesses have testified at a hearing last month to determine whether Thibodeau's 1995 conviction should be overturned.
There was no "smoking gun" linking Thibodeau to the abduction of Allen, then 18, from a convenience store in New Haven or her presumed murder. There was no body, no confession to police and no DNA evidence.
Related story: Who's who in the Heidi Allen case
Here's a tally of who's implicated whom:
JAMES STEEN
Seven people say they have evidence linking him to the crime. Steen denies any involvement in the crime. He has not been charged.
James Steen denied having any involvement in Heidi Allen's kidnapping or the concealment of her body while testifying Jan. 13, 2015 at a hearing about the 1994 kidnapping. Steen is serving life in prison for killing his wife and her boyfriend.Gary Walts | gwalts@syracuse.com
Tonya Priest: She says Steen confessed to her in 2006 that he, Breckenridge and Bohrer kidnapped Allen because she was going to report drug dealers to police. Steen told her they killed Allen then hid her remains under the floor of a cabin in the woods off Rice Road in Mexico, Priest said.
Megan Shaw: Steen told her he helped dispose of Allen's body after others kidnapped and killed her, Shaw testified. He did so to join a motorcycle gang, Shaw said Steen told her.
Joe Mannino Jr.: He said Steen admitted hauling a crushed van to Canada that had been used in the Allen kidnapping. Steen and Mannino were in the Oswego County Jail in 2011 when Steen made the admission, Mannino said.
Bill Pierce: He says he saw Steen punch a woman in the back of the head and load her into a van on Easter morning 1994 at the store where Allen was kidnapped. Pierce did not tell authorities until 2014 about what he said he saw.
Ronald Clarke: In October, Clarke told sheriff's investigators that Steen told him a few years after the kidnapping that "Heidi Allen was long gone to Canada."
"He was basically laughing at the sheriffs because he thought they didn't know what they were doing," Clarke said.
Clarke came forward in October after seeing news accounts about Steen's possible involvement. But his written statement wasn't turned over to Thibodeau's lawyers until two weeks ago.
Amanda Braley: She testified that sometime between 2000 and 2006 she overheard Steen telling people, "I will never see a day in prison for what we did to Heidi."
Jennifer Wescott: In a phone call that she didn't know was being recorded and monitored by investigators in 2013, Wescott admitted that Breckenridge, Steen and Bohrer brought the kidnapped Allen to her home in 1994.
ROGER BRECKENRIDGE
Seven witnesses say they have evidence he was involved. Breckenridge denies having anything to do with Allen's kidnapping. He has not been charged.
Roger Breckenridge denied he had any involvement in the 1994 kidnapping and presumed killing of 18-year-old Heidi Allen when he testified Jan. 13. 2015 at a hearing in Oswego, N.Y. Gary Walts | gwalts@syracuse.com
Amanda Braley: At a party at Wescott's family's home in 2003, Breckenridge said "he took that bitch to the scrapyard in a van, they had it crushed and it was shipped to Canada," Braley testified. Breckenridge made similar admissions repeatedly between 2000 and 2006, Braley said.
Chris Combs:. Breckenridge admitted burning her body in a stove and hiding it in a vehicle that was to be scrapped, Combs told investigators recently. Breckenridge told Combs that the kidnapping involved "a local organization that would take care of things/people."
Jennifer Wescott: In addition to the recorded phone call, Wescott told sheriff's investigators in August that shortly after Allen's kidnapping Breckenridge admitted to her that Allen was burned in a wood stove and "taken care of in a van." Wescott also revealed that Breckenridge's sister told her to "keep her mouth shut" about his involvement in Allen's disappearance.
James Steen: He testified that Breckenridge told him 20 years ago that Allen's body was in a crushed vehicle that Steen had hauled to Canada. Steen said he thought Breckenridge was "just blowing steam."
Jessica Howard: She told a Syracuse.com reporter Breckenridge's family has told her he and Steen kidnapped and killed Allen because she was planning to turn them in to police for selling drugs. Howard, who married into the Breckenridge family, said she alerted sheriff's deputies in 2004 and 2011, but they never investigated her allegations.
Cynthia Taylor: She says Breckenridge's ex-wife, Tracy Breckenridge, admitted 21 years ago that in 1994 he and three others had planned a drug deal at the store where Heidi Allen was a cashier. Tracy told Taylor and others that those people "did something to a girl" because the victim was going to snitch on a drug deal, Taylor said in a recent statement to sheriff's investigators.
James Abbott: He says that in 1994 Tracy Breckenridge admitted to him that her then-husband burned Allen's body.
MICHAEL BOHRER
Michael Bohrer testified Jan. 14 and 15, 2015 at a court hearing in Oswego, N.Y., that he had nothing to do with Allen's disappearance. Bohrer admitted that for years he independently investigated the crime. David Lassman | dlassman@syracuse.com
Three witnesses have implicated him. Bohrer says he was not involved in the kidnapping. He has not been charged.
Tyler Hayes: He testified that Bohrer was telling people at the Liberty Bell bar in Mexico in 2000 that he knew who killed Allen and where her body was. Bohrer started sobbing and said he didn't want to deal with the guilt, Hayes testified.
Danielle Babcock:She testified that, when she worked for Bohrer in 2001 or 2002, he frequently told her and other female employees that "he would do us like he did Heidi."
Jennifer Wescott: She acknowledged in the recorded phone call that Bohrer was with Breckenridge and Steen when they brought the kidnapped Allen to her home in 1994.
GARY THIBODEAU
Three witnesses have implicated him. Thibodeau, 61, was convicted in 1995 of kidnapping and presumably killing Allen. He's serving 25 years to life in prison. He's maintained he's innocent. Thibodeau's brother, Richard, was acquitted by a jury in 1995.
Gary Thibodeau consults with his lawyer Lisa Peebles at a court hearing in Oswego, N.Y., about the 1994 kidnapping of Heidi Allen. Thibodeau is the only person convicted of the crime. His brother, Richard, was acquitted by a jury in 1995. David Lassman | dlassman@syracuse.com
Robert Baldasaro: He says Thibodeau made admissions when they were both inmates at a Massachusetts jail shortly after the kidnapping. "He told me 'the police back in New York think me and my brother kidnapped a girl from a convenience store, but they will never prove it,'" Baldasaro testified.
James McDonald: He was another Massachusetts jail inmate who testified in 1995 that Thibodeau admitted that that he used cocaine with Allen. No other witness said Allen was a drug user.
James Abbott: He says Tracy Breckenridge told him in 1994 that a Thibodeau worked together with her husband to burn Allen's body in an outdoor furnace. In a statement to sheriff's investigators, Abbott did not identify which Thibodeau brother he was talking about.
Christopher Bivens. He testified in the Thibodeaus' trials that he was driving by the D&W Convenience store Easter morning when he saw two men leading a young woman to a van, and that one of them had her in a bear hug. Bivens testified that a rust spot and the van's bumper allowed him to positively identify the van as Richard Thibdoeau's. In previous statements to police, Bivens said he was uncertain of the van's make or color, and he hadn't remembered the rust spot or bumper.
He did not identify either of the Thibodeaus as the men he saw at the scene.
Nancy Fabian. She testified in the Thibodeaus' trials that she saw a van swerving behind her as she drove on Route 104 in Mexico Easter morning, and that the male driver of the van was reaching behind him as if to push something down. She later identified Richard Thibodeau's van as that vehicle.
She did not identify either of the Thibodeaus as the man in the van.
Contact John O'Brien at jobrien@syracuse.com or 315-470-2187